Insanely Brilliant – “The Play That Goes Wrong” Celebrates the Power of Incongruity at the Orpheum

Photo: Jeremy Daniel
Photo: Jeremy Daniel

Photo by Jeremy Daniel.

Incongruity can be a great generator of laughter when harnessed to a well-shaped comedy. The playing of opposites simultaneously can also trigger laughter. What makes The Play That Goes Wrong so uproariously successful is its wacky manifestation of both of these overarching elements.

However, the paradox as applied to this insanely brilliant work is that it’s all about being out-of-shape in the worst imaginable way. Lewis, Sayer, and Shields’s script now manifested at the Orpheum is simultaneously two-fold.


  1. The setting is a drama society production stage whereon a late Victorian style murder mystery whodunnit starts performing. The set the production is being presented on falls apart around them—props go missing that specifically apply to the text the actors speak—mis-timed entrances and exits run amok! The mad misfires continue for the length of the entire production.


  1. The whodunnit requires the cast play their roles with precision snobbery or deference to the snobs—the polar opposite of the definition of haphazard. An orderly mileu congealed in hierarchy. You’ve seen the style in old movies on late night television.


Photo by Jeremy Daniel.

These are your typical wealthy English types, accustomed to their privilege in a beautifully stately home where characters speak and behave impeccably, with a stuffy sense of propriety. The whole class stereotype is there, acted out shamelessly and hilariously by a gloriously nimble cast that perfectly times and paces the “mistakes-on-purpose” enactment of a play presentation that is as imperfect as one could imagine.

Photo by Jeremy Daniel.

Further opposites and incongruity manifest as this play-within-a-play’s technicians are as contemporary as, well… Duran Duran. From where I stand at least, Duran Duran is contemporary.

Nitpick: they should have played the exhilarating Rio for the curtain. At any rate, do yourself a favor and see The Play That Goes Wrong.

The Play That Goes Wrong 
Through May 12
Orpheum Theatre, 910 Hennepin Ave., Minneapolis

Lavender Magazine

5100 Eden Ave, Suite 107 • Edina, MN 55436 • 612.436.4660

©2023 Lavender Media, Inc.