Skirting The Issues: Practice

Photo by BigStock/Oobqoo
Photo by BigStock/Oobqoo

Photo by BigStock/Oobqoo

I know it’s Pride Month and a time to celebrate being GLBT. By all means, go out and feel good about being queer. You’ve certainly earned it!

However, I’m not in the mood to celebrate and I suspect most transgender Americans similarly aren’t feeling too festive. Yes, what follows is a bit of Debbie Downer; that’s just how it is for my community now, day in and day out.

First, a bit of history.

In September 1935, at Adolf Hitler’s urging, the German Reichstag passed what became known as the “Nuremberg Laws”—the first of a series of state-sanctioned measures to distinguish Germans of Jewish ancestry from “pure” Germans. One of those measures was to prohibit marriage between Jews and non-Jews; the same law prohibited sexual intercourse between such parties (heterosexual sex, that is; same-sex relations were illegal regardless of ancestry).

Another measure set forth the requirements for German citizenship, including voting rights based on a person’s percentage of Jewish ancestry. From that flowed wholesale discrimination against Jews in employment, education, and the military. Of course, we know what eventually happened to Jewish people in Germany and then later, in greater Europe and Russia.

I raise this because as I see it, certain sectors of our government have undertaken the American equivalent of the Nuremberg Laws vis-à-vis transgender humans. Please let me lay out some of the particulars:

  • In February 2017, existing Department of Education guidance letters that had been protecting transgender students relative to bathroom and locker room usage were voided. The move put trans students at the mercy of state and local school authorities, many of which have since banned trans students from using facilities that correspond with their gender identity. This has resulted in increased bullying and violence against trans-identifying students.
  • The ban of 15,000 transgender service members from the military, which went into full effect earlier this year, effectively forced trans service members into a Hobson’s choice of living as their authentic selves or forfeiting years of military service, including military benefits.
  • In October of 2017, the Department of Justice reversed its position on whether federal law prohibits employment discrimination against transgender persons; up until then, the DOJ had prosecuted lawsuits against employers engaging in trans-related discrimination. A year later, the DOJ told the U.S. Supreme Court that employers are free to discriminate against transgender employees.
  • In May 2018, the U.S. Bureau of Prisons rolled back a policy that required federal correction facilities to house transgender offenders according to their gender identity; the newly-announced policy reverted to housing according to birth gender, thereby exposing transgender persons in federal confinement to exponentially greater violence.
  • In late April this year, the Department of Human Services announced plans to eliminate protections for trans persons under the Affordable Care Act. This means that medical providers would be free to discriminate against transgender patients. It also could mean that insurers would have the right to declare being transgender a “pre-existing condition” and a basis for outright denying us access to health insurance, even if we can afford it.

This is just some of what our government is doing to transgender persons. It doesn’t encompass how individual states are further marginalizing my community through bathroom bills, ID requirements and other measures.

For those who may feel some comfort because they aren’t transgender, it’s my view that the government is effectively practicing Nuremberg-style policies on the transgender community; after all, we’re an easy mark. Once the government nails the template for wholesale legal erasure, it’s not much of a stretch to see the reach expanding—to same-sex marriage, or to persons who aren’t Christian, or to women who want to make their own personal medical/health decisions, or to those born outside the United States but granted U.S. citizenship.

I know, some of you are now labeling me an alarmist and perhaps even a kook. However, I’m sure that way back in the early 1930s, social commentators also scoffed when the German leadership first began to target the Jews. As reported in an April 30th Newsweek piece, a new book by Tom Phillips, HUMANS: A Brief History of How We F*cked It All Up, recounts that, “Hitler was actually an incompetent, lazy egomaniac and his government was an absolute clown show.”

Yet, that very same clown show became exceedingly efficient at exterminating whole groups of humans—by the end, more than six million humans who were “Other.”

So, as Pride Month 2019 unfolds, I won’t be thinking of celebrating, but just of surviving.

I refuse to be a victim.


Ellen (Ellie) Krug is the author of Getting to Ellen: A Memoir about Love, Honesty and Gender Change (2013). She speaks and trains on diversity and inclusion topics; visit where you can also sign up for her e-newsletter, The Ripple. She welcomes your comments at [email protected].

Lavender Magazine

5100 Eden Ave, Suite 107 • Edina, MN 55436 • 612.436.4660

©2022 Lavender Media, Inc.